Want to Improve Your Writing? Join a Critique Group
During the essay class I finished recently, the instructor impressed upon us the importance of finding a critique group to join. I’ve been part of a nonfiction critique group that meets monthly for more than two years now and it’s the best thing I’ve ever done for my writing, so I could certainly agree with her. And the more I participated in the class, giving and receiving feedback on pieces the class participants shared, the more strongly I came to believe that the instructor was right.
Critique groups have plenty of benefits:
1. Creativity loves company. I’m a firm believer that where two or more creative spirits gather, creativity will flow. Conversations, suggestions and even criticisms can spark ideas for new pieces. As your work (or that of fellow members) is discussed, excitement can build for writing or other creative pursuits.
2. It’s like school, only more fun. As part of a critique group you’ll find yourself learning more than you might have imagined. Some people in your group may be grammar Nazis. Some may have an eye for plot inconsistency. Others may be able to pull the real story out of you by asking the perfect questions. Not only that, but each member will bring unique experiences and individual belief systems to their writing that might expand your own ideas, thoughts and beliefs. If open to the topics, comments and suggestions of others, group members can learn and grow as writers (and maybe as people, too).
3. Group members are more honest than your mom. Sure, it’s nice to hear “It’s wonderful!” and “This is the best thing I’ve ever read!” from the friends and family you share your work with. But those comments, as true as they may be on some level, are not going to improve your writing. Being part of a critique group gives members permission to provide you with honest, constructive feedback that will help everyone in the group improve their work. And being open to receive and apply this feedback will make your work stronger and make you a better writer. Take those comments from your Mom and let them bolster you when you’re feeling like a hack, but make sure you have a group of readers who will give you an honest and helpful critique so that you can hear “It’s wonderful!” from editors and publishers some day.
4. Deadlines work wonders. I’ve found that having to regularly produce work to share is one of the most useful side-effects of joining a critique group. Instead of being able to put off working on your next essay or chapter or short story, you have a built-in responsibility to be regularly producing and editing pieces.
5. Fellow writers know what you’re going through. Becoming a critique group member is like joining a support group. We build each other up and encourage one another when we need it. When necessary, we also challenge each other to change and improve, to grow and stretch ourselves as writers.
With the help of a small group of dedicated writers, I’ve become a better writer myself, plain and simple. But being part of the group isn’t always easy. Membership requires commitment, dedication, time, and energy that I sometimes don’t have, but I stick it out and am better for it.
I challenge you, if you’re not already a member of a critique group, find one or start one. Now. Don’t wait. The quality of your writing may depend on it.
Posted in from the trenches, the writing life, writing in general








March 14th, 2010 at 8:18 pm
I want to do a post on HOW to find a critique group… Because sometimes that can be more difficult than deciding to join one!
March 29th, 2010 at 9:05 am
[...] of critique groups. (If you’re still not convinced you should join one, read these posts by Ami Spencer, Chip MacGregor, and Kristi Helvig.) But Ami Spencer at Write Out Loud and I wanted to take that [...]